Europe Steps Up the Fight Against the Sale of Defective Tires

John Stone
Posted on June 21, 2016

The sale of defective or part-worn tires remains a thorn in the side of the tire industry around the world. We know that unsafe, unlawful tires cause death and mayhem on our roads, but the sale of part-worns is a global problem that appears to be reluctantly tolerated... that is, until now.

In a surprise development, the Republic of Ireland (which is part of the European Union) recently announced that the country has introduced a new “fixed penalty charge” along with penalty points on drivers’ licenses with immediate effect for anyone caught driving with a defective or severely worn tire. The new regulations came into force in mid-April with the introduction of a new fixed fine of 80 euros plus two penalty points on the driver’s license on immediate payment or a more severe four points following a court conviction.

To say this decision has sent shock waves through the European and UK tire industries would be an understatement, but one that has been applauded and will be watched very closely in the coming months.

Ireland has an appalling road safety record which is backed by the fact that surveys indicate that during the past five years worn tires were the most significant single factor for the cause of almost two thirds of vehicle collisions in Ireland resulting in 71 deaths. At the same time, to further compound the extreme tire safety problem in Europe, a recent local tire tread depth survey carried out in neighboring Northern Ireland (part of the UK), over 3,000 tires were removed from cars and light commercial vans that were found to be below the legal tread depth limit of 1.6 mm.

This can be the shocking result of riding on part-worn tires on European highways.
This can be the shocking result of riding on part-worn tires on European highways.
Therefore, it is hardly surprising that the UK-based National Tyre Distributors Association (NTDA) was truly alarmed by these shocking findings. They confirm and support the survey carried out in the UK last year conducted by Tyresafe which revealed over 25% of drivers were openly replacing tires with part-worns which in some cases were already illegal.

This very disturbing development supports the common theory in the industry in Europe that poor tire management and maintenance by consumers combined with a distinct lack of enforcement means the problem of part-worn tires appears to be getting even worse.

In my opinion, although this new chapter in the fight against defective or part-worn tires has originated in Ireland and the UK it will inevitably be taken up by most if not all European countries in due course. I recently chatted with NTDA Director Stefan Hay who informed me that this latest ruling in Ireland holds huge pressures for both the European Union countries and the UK. If the current ruling of just 1.6 mm tread depth stays in place as the legal requirement for the foreseeable future then in his opinion we must start pressuring for more effective tire law enforcement measures to come into place as soon as possible.

Hay adds, “In Europe, most vehicle manufacturers are investing a great deal of money to effectively improve vehicle driver and passenger safety. But I believe the majority of this work is being wasted if the tires fitted to vehicles could eventually become unsafe and illegal.”

How these latest revelations on the danger of fitting part-worn or defective tires will affect the sales for the growing number of emerging tire dealers in European countries who appear to be in business only to make a “fast buck or two” without any concern for driver safety is anyone’s guess, but I firmly believe that what has just happened in Ireland in terms of dishing out instant heavy fines for driving with illegal tires might just have a welcoming and long overdue effect on drivers thinking twice about saving a few pounds or euros on significantly inferior tires.

I have no doubt that what has recently happened in the Republic of Ireland will have a ground-breaking effect on the future of the sale of defective tires in Europe in the near future.  

John Stone has been working within the global tire industry for the past 24 years. In 2004 he launched his own consulting company, Sapphire Media Services, which caters to business media clients around the globe. Stone also writes for tire and automotive-related publications in Europe, South Africa and Asia.

To read more European Notebook columns, click:

Tire Labeling Update: Increased Surveillance Should FIx a Loophole

From a Rubber Pattern to Total Control! Future Tires Will be a Source of Invaluable Information

An Endless Battle for Legal Tires in Europe

European and American Wheel Alignment Markets Work Almost in Unison

Taking a New, Determined Route Against Part-Worn Tires

Related Topics: Defective Tires, European Notebook, John Stone, Part-worn tires

Comments ( 0 )
More Stories
In addition to warning its employees on the dangers of texting and driving, Ramona Tire promotes that message to the public with its “Please make it home safe today” digital billboard on I-215 west of Hemet, Calif. (see sidebar).

How Is the ‘Health’ of Your Business Insurance Coverage?

Many of us make it a point to see our doctor for regular checkups. Doing so gives the physician the opportunity to assess the current condition of our health, and gives us a chance to ask questions about medical issues or concerns. A thorough exam can help to diagnose early symptoms and gives the doctor an opportunity to offer recommendations and advice for a healthier lifestyle.

Lynda Kester of Big Red Tire Pros and Quick Chadwick, director of marketing for Tire Pros, have some fun with the audience.

Photos: Go With the Pros, as in Tire Pros

Attendance at the 2018 Tire Pros Dealer Business Conference was a record -- 965 people, including spouses. Here's what went on during the event in San Antonio Feb. 8-11.  

Department of Labor audit outcomes in the automotive service industry.

Wage and Hour Regulations: You Probably are Not in Compliance

Owners and operators of tire dealerships and automotive service shops, no matter how large or small, are being targeted by the United States Department of Labor’s Wage and Hour Division. This is the federal agency that enforces minimum wage, record keeping and overtime rules.

Two-time NASCAR champion Greg Biffle has joined Continental as a social media correspondent. His first assignment was driving an off-road course on the General Grabber A/TX. He got stuck in a mud pit.

Photos: A Look at 2 New General Tires

Continental Tire the Americas LLC invited Modern Tire Dealer to a launch event of two tires on opposite ends of the spectrum — the G-Max RS is an ultra-high performance summer tire, and the Grabber A/TX, an all-terrain tire.

Louis Gomez of Prescott (Ariz.) Tire Pros & Automotive Service, and his wife, Angela, received the Tire Pros Excellence in Engagement Award from Bob Bittner, left, and Quick Chadwick, right.

Tire Pros Develops a Playbook to Guide its Franchisees

Tire Pros Francorp. is "dealer-driven." That differentiates the franchise program from similar programs, says Ron Sinclair, senior vice president of retail strategy and partnerships for its parent company, American Tire Distributors Inc.

Be the First to Know

Get the latest news and most popular articles from MTD delivered straight to your inbox. Stay on top of the tire industry and don't miss a thing!