‘Go Online,’ They Said, ‘It’s Easier’: We’re Caught in the Transformational Global Vortex

Wayne Williams
Posted on February 8, 2018

Here’s the premise of this article: Online shopping is not yet as seamless as it’s going to be, and traditional retailing is less appealing and in many ways less satisfying than it used to be.

Like many shoppers, my household is increasingly more reliant on some of the benefits of online shopping. Last month, like many people, my wife and I uttered the proverbial holiday season mantra, “We want to get our Christmas shopping done early this year.” As usual, we ended up doing it in waves. Wave one was done in early December. By mid-December, we’d started wave two, or as I called it, “The (near) final assault.”

Holiday gift giving tends to be a moving target, so I decided to employ some advanced tactical thinking last year: Go online for wave one to knock down the big items, and then back-fill the balance with local shopping. Brilliant, I thought. Upon deciding on the items to be purchased, we felt pretty good; an excellent balance of dollars spent versus value received. However, from the get-go, my brilliant plan began to unwind.

The last Sunday afternoon in November, a full month before Christmas Day, the Bulldog, aka my wife, attacked our plan with a vengeance.

There are several key things to note here in the shifting landscape of 21st Century shopping. First, minimum advertised pricing; the item we wanted was priced the same everywhere. I’m not surprised as this has become an increasingly common practice in many industries; tires and automotive aftermarket are no different (pretty much). I have respect for the companies that manage pricing integrity across their distribution channels. Second point, online research is good, online purchasing not so much; it’s rather clunky and has very high abandonment rates.

Given that the pricing was the same everywhere, we selected Williams and Sonoma. If the price is the same, go to the place with the best reputation. Well, try as she may, the Bulldog was unable to get Williams and Sonoma’s website to accept our order. Me, Mr. Solution, instructed Bulldog to have them delivered or we would pick them up, “them” being the new Calphalon stackable pots and pans. I knew that pots and pans were going to be easy because there are no options, no color choices, no optional accessories, everything in one box, one size fits all. The Williams and Sonoma website, though beautiful in its “holiday theme,” was a total bust; unable to see store inventory, we abandoned the prestigious retailer.

The Bulldog, with her usual high percentage kill rate, moved on with determination. The net result, after checking some of the largest national retailers, she ended up buying factory direct. I’m not a fan of factory direct because no matter how much a manufacturer promises online, manufacturers are typically poor online retailers, strong promises but weak results (like some tire manufacturers). By mid-December; no pots and pans, no tracking numbers. I’m preparing for disappointment. Can’t I just point and click and be happy?

Retailing is evolving dramatically, both online and in-store. Today’s retailing is caught in a transformational global vortex, a whirlpool of shifting activity that is transforming how goods and services are currently delivered to the marketplace, but varying greatly by product category.  About 90% of all retail transactions are done in brick-and-mortar locations, with the remaining 10% done online. Some day we won’t see the process as either/or, either in-store or online, but a more homogenous process that is functionally more consumer centric.

However, I wished I could drive to the mall, park my truck, enter the busy store, make my purchase, stop at gift wrap, drive home, and place my gifts under our tree. The experience I described is no longer available at most retail locations. My plan was for a seamless satisfying experience; what I got instead was a retail world in transition.

My suggestion for independent tire dealers in 2018 is to redefine and refine the brick-and-mortar experience. Ask yourself what your customers really want, and then ask your customers what they really want.

Over the years, I’ve read in-depth studies commissioned both from major rubber companies and retailers. I sum it up as follows ...

* Customers want fast, friendly service that costs less!

*  “Fast” means prompt convenience.

*  “Friendly” means knowledgeable and helpful.

*  “Costs less” means value and bang for the buck.

*  Customers will find what they want, online or in-store!

*  You’ll need uncompromising consumer-centric service  to compete.

Prepare for the unavoidable increase in digital retailing that is coming with a vengeance!    ■

Wayne Williams is president of Wayne Williams Marketing, a marketing and branding company with emphasis on retail “counter intelligence.” Located in La Habra, Calif., he can be reached via email at

To read more Counter Intelligence articles, see:

Branding Is a Beacon: The TIme Is Right for You to Rethink and Rebrand

We Are Retailers: We Must Keep an Eye on the Details in Retail

Simple Truths in Retailing that Never Change

I Got Schooled by a School Teacher

Related Topics: branding, Counter Intelligence, Wayne Williams

Wayne Williams Wayne Williams
Comments ( 0 )
More Stories

Monro Has Bought 35 Tire Stores in the Last 10 Months

The strategy at Monro Inc. is to keep the foot on the gas when it comes to acquisitions. And that's evident already in 2018, with the purchase of three retail stores from Valley Tire Co. Inc. in Pennsylvania, plus an agreement to complete another deal with seven stores before the end of March.  

Members of the ZC Rubber team are pictured at the company's 2018 dealer conference.

ZC Rubber Hosts Dealers in Bangkok

Zhongce Rubber Group Co Ltd. (ZC Rubber) discussed plans to improve market share with dealers attending its 2018 distributor conference in Bangkok on Jan. 28.

Tom Eisenberg says he thinks his grandfather would shed a tear or two if he saw the mural, and "say it's great and keep moving. He was not that sentimental about things. He was a U.S. Marine."

West Coast Tire Pays Tribute to Its Founder Bob Mirman

After Bob Mirman, the founder of West Coast Tire and Service Inc., died in October, his grandson wanted to find a way to honor the man who led him into the tire business. So he put a customer — an artist — to work on a 30-foot mural.  

Tomoshige "Tomo" Mizutani took over as CEO and president of Toyo Tire North America OE Sales LLC on Jan. 1.

Toyo Announces More Organizational and Assignment Changes

Toyo Tire & Rubber Co. has made changes to its corporate structure, continuing its goal of revising its organizational structure by operational function "with the intention of reinforcing managment through coordination among each headquarter," and the corporate functions associated with them.


PitStop's 318 Stores Join Point S Germany

PitStop, a chain of 318 tire and auto service stores in Germany, has joined Point S Germany. The merger gives Point S 870 retail locations throughout Germany.  

Be the First to Know

Get the latest news and most popular articles from MTD delivered straight to your inbox. Stay on top of the tire industry and don't miss a thing!