Ad Wars: Discount Tire Versus Conrad's Tire Express

Bob Ulrich
Posted on February 16, 2017

This screen capture is from a local Conrad's ad that ran on the Feb. 15 broadcast of ABC World News Tonight.
This screen capture is from a local Conrad's ad that ran on the Feb. 15 broadcast of ABC World News Tonight.
Last night I watched back-to-back tire advertisements on the national evening news that took different approaches to wooing the customer. One was from Discount Tire. The other was from Conrad’s Tire Express & Total Car Care.

Both are listed in the Modern Tire Dealer 100. Discount Tire is number one, a national chain with more than 925 stores in 32 states. Conrad’s is number 30, a regional chain with 36 stores in Northeast Ohio. Here is a breakdown of their ads, each 30 seconds long.

Discount Tire (Reinalt-Thomas Corp.)

“Discount Tire is the place where America saves on tires,” said the announcer. And the ad touted a Presidents Day sale this Friday and Saturday (Feb. 17-18). Consumers can get up to a $100 VISA Prepaid Card “when you buy select sets of tires.” No brands were given.

Wait, there’s more savings. You also can get a $100 prepaid card when you buy any set of wheels.

And if that isn’t enough savings – potentially $200 – the ad said you can save even more if you use your Discount Tire credit card.

In summary, buy a certain set of tires, a set of wheels and use your Discount Tire credit card and you can save up to $320.

Conrad’s Tire Express & Total Car Care (Conrad’s Tire Service Inc.)

“Check engine lights. Radiators. Brakes. Belts. Shocks. Tune-ups. You name the service, you name the vehicle, there’s only one name you need. Conrad’s.”

The actor talking in the ad was whispering, because Conrad’s is known for whispering its name in its television advertising.

Then the ad promoted a $17.95 lube, oil and filter special that included a four-tire rotation and “a free courtesy inspection” – a $38.95 value.

“Service you can trust? Do what nearly a thousand of smart people do every day,” said the actor.” Just whisper.” And then someone whispered “Conrad’s.” The ad didn't mention tires at all.

Discount Tire didn't list brands in its Presidents Day ad on ABC World News Tonight, but this screen capture of the tire tread that appeared in the ad reveals one of the brands -- although it is disguised with a George Washington wig. Which brand is it?
Discount Tire didn't list brands in its Presidents Day ad on ABC World News Tonight, but this screen capture of the tire tread that appeared in the ad reveals one of the brands -- although it is disguised with a George Washington wig. Which brand is it?

Here are my observations.

First, I don’t know if the Discount Tire ad was national or not. Because there are 18 states in which the company does not have a tire store, I can’t believe the ad ran during the national news broadcast in those states. My guess is it ran just in Northeast Ohio; Discount Tire has three stores in the area.

Second, each company promoted what it does best. Discount Tire doesn’t offer any automotive services. It just sells tires and wheels (and mounts and balances them). Conrad’s offers both undercar and under-hood services.

Third, I found it odd the tire ads ran one after the other. Perhaps Conrad’s asked if another tire dealer was running an ad, and asked to follow it. I don’t know what the policy is for local stations when it comes to advertising -- maybe when one company buys an ad, they call its competitors and say, "Hey, your competitor is running an ad. You should too."

Fourth, Conrad’s has 36 stores and, according to the ad, nearly a thousand customers a day. I am going to estimate that at least 950 customers could be considered “nearly 1,000.” That works out to 26 to 27 cars per outlet per day. I don’t know the car count at the three Discount Tire stores in Northeast Ohio, but MTD estimates the average Discount Tire store sells more than 80 tires a day.

Fun fact: Presidents Day refers to only one president, George Washington. The federal government has not adopted “Presidents Day” as the official name of what is legally the “Washington’s Birthday” holiday.

Related Topics: B.O.B., Conrad's Tire Express, Discount Tire, TV advertising

Bob Ulrich Editor
Comments ( 2 )
  • See all comments
  • dennis

     | about 2 days ago

    you did not come to a conclusion, yes boxes are tough on the numbers. Have you been in them? shopped them? I have I find indifferent service, lots of I don't know about that , poor wait time ,and you never have the same guys twice. these same things can happen w any tire/service shop. Our job is to make a personal connection w the customer. Treat them as you would like to be treated. Both outlets can forget that item

More Stories
Bobby Hendry from 31 Inc. was from one of 80-plus vendors at the Tire Factory trade show. Here he talks to Mike Fleming, equipment supply manager for the dealer group, and Marc Thompson from Point S Everett in Everett, Wash.
News

Point S Rebranding Exceeds Expectations in the U.S., and Points to More Growth

Tire Factory Inc. members have rebranded the vast majority of their 206 stores to the Point S banner at a breakneck pace. And leaders of the Oregon-based cooperative are unveiling new programs with two big hopes: the momentum of current members continues, and more independent tire dealers join their network.

ATV has added 6 stores to its network of American Tire Depot stores in California.
News

ATV Opens 6 American Tire Depot Stores

ATV Inc. has acquired six stores in the greater Los Angeles metro area. The purchase expands ATV's network of American Tire Depot stores to 98 outlets, all in California.

News

MATDA Joins TIA's Social Media Platform

The Mid-America Tire Dealers Association (MATDA) has joined the social media content platform developed by the Tire Industry Association (TIA) and the Automotive Marketing Foundation (AMF).

News

Toyo’s Net Tire Sales Drop 6.7% in 2016

Toyo Tire & Rubber Co. Ltd. reported a net loss of 12.3 billion yen on net sales of 381.6 billion yen for its fiscal year ended Dec. 31, 2016. That compares to net income of 1.6 billion yen on net sales of 407.8 billion yen for fiscal 2015.

News

Radar Tires Clinch Second Place At The Battle At Primm

Nothing could not stop Kelton Glaszczak and Richard Glaszczak from racing to the podium at the SNORE King Shocks Battle at Primm. The Glaszczak team, drivers of the Class 10 No. 1073 Richards Performance Muffler B&R Buggie, finished second in class during the two-day event. This marks the first podium for Radar Tires in 2017.

News

Smith Coming Onboard With RBR For Daytona, 2017 NCWTS Season

Regan Smith will be behind the wheel of the NASCAR Camping World Truck Series (NCWTS) No. 92 BTS Tire and Wheel Distributors/Goodyear Commercial Tire & Service Network/Advance Auto Parts/Valvoline Ford F-150 for Daytona and 11 other series events in 2017.

Be the First to Know

Get the latest news and most popular articles from MTD delivered straight to your inbox. Stay on top of the tire industry and don't miss a thing!