Consumer Reports Ranks All-Season Tires -- and More

Bob Ulrich
Posted on March 13, 2017

“Nine percent of car, SUV, truck and van crashes are caused by tires that aren’t up to snuff. Here’s how to determine whether the ones on your car need to be replaced -- before they fail.”

Those were the opening words by Jon Linkov in the April 2017 issue of "Consumer Reports (CR)." He credits the estimate to a study by the National Highway Traffic Safety Administration (NHTSA).

I wondered about that statistic and its implications, so I looked up the April 2012 study. It defined tire problems as follows:

* Blowouts or flat tires.

* Tire or wheel deficiency.

* Tire or wheel failure.

* Tire degradation.

How NHTSA defined those problems is critical to understanding the survey. It did so based on each problem’s relationship to the crash. “Tire or wheel deficiency” is assessed as an "associated factor" prior to the crash. They are documented factors “that might have played a role in crash occurrence.”

 “Tire or wheel failure” and “tire degradation” are assessed as "critical reasons for the crash." They are the “immediate reason for the critical event” and are often “the last failure in the causal chain.”

“Blowouts or flat tires” are assessed as the "critical pre-cash events." They are documented as “the circumstances that made the crash imminent.”

What are the implications of this statement? Even though the CR story goes on to rate the top all-season, performance all-season and UHP all-season tires, Linkov does not equate brand with tire failure. Neither does NHTSA, which even goes so far as to say none of its definitions “implies that a particular tire problem caused the crash.”

In many ways, both the story and NHTSA point fingers at the consumer for poor tire maintenance. That’s where I believe the responsibility for the majority of tire failures belongs. Add in accidental tire failure (i.e., running over something that causes the tire to fail, and as such is generally no one’s fault) and it becomes apparent tire manufacturers are too often blamed for crashes and crash-related fatalities.

Speaking of those CR ratings, here’s a quick summary of the magazine’s recommended all-season tires. The cost-per-mile of each, based on the price of the tire and its limited tread wear warranty, is in parentheses.


1.Michelin Defender (13 cents)

2. Continental TrueContact (18 cents)

3. General Altimax RT43 (14 cents)

4. Pirelli P4 Four Seasons (10 cents)

Performance All-Season (H-rated)

1. Continental PureContact (21 cents)

2. Pirelli Cinturato P7 All Season Plus (15 cents)

3. Michelin Premier A/S (16 cents)

Performance All-Season (V-rated)

1. Continental PureContact (20 cents)

2. Michelin Premier A/S (18 cents)

3. Pirelli Cinturato P7 All Season Plus (17 cents)

UHP All-Season

1. Michelin Pilot Sport A/S 3+ (28 cents)

2. Pirelli P Zero All Season Plus (25 cents)

3. Continental ExtremeContact DWS06 (31 cents)

4. BFGoodrich g-Force Comp-2 A/S (19 cents)

The tires are ranked by point total, with the overall score based on up to 14 tests.

Related Topics: Consumer Reports, Continental PureContact, Continental TrueContact, General Altimax, Michelin Defender, Michelin Premier, NHTSA, Pirelli Cinturato, Pirelli P Zero

Bob Ulrich Editor
Comments ( 4 )
  • See all comments
  • pre user

     | about 2 years ago

    NHTSA let keygate get by them who would trust them with tire durability ratings ?

More Stories
BKT says its sponsorship of Monster Jam has contributed "significantly to enhance brand recognition at the international level."

BKT Heads to the Monster Jam World Finals

Balkrishna Industries Ltd. (BKT) is gearing up for a big weekend in Las Vegas at the Monster Jam World Finals XIX. As the exclusive tire manufacturer of Monster Jam, BKT will be put to work in the arena, and fans will party in the BKT Village.


Trump Proposes More Tariffs on Chinese Products

President Donald Trump is stepping up his tough talk on trade with action, and has asked U.S. Trade Representative Robert Lighthizer to identify Chinese products that should be subject to tariffs.

The Haas VF-18 races for the first time this weekend in Australia.

Haas F1 Team: Albert Park Practice Recap

The opening round of the 2018 FIA Formula One World Championship began with practice Friday at Melbourne Grand Prix Circuit as teams prepared for the Australian Grand Prix Sunday.

Michelin says the Pilot Sport 4 S tire offers unprecedented driving pleasure, exceptional steering precision and tremendous directional stability, while also providing maximum grip on wet or dry roads.

Michelin Expands Pilot Sport 4S Coverage

Michelin North America Inc. has added 34 sizes to the Pilot Sport 4S. The ultra-high-performance tire is now available in 76 sizes with original equipment and replacement applications.


PR Journalist Dave Russ Dies at 71

David Russ, former public relations team member for Goodyear Tire and Rubber Co. and Firestone Tire & Rubber Co., has died. He was 71.

Midtronics says the new MSP-070 power supply charger is an effective and easy-to-use charging solution for showroom and reflash applications.

New Midtronics Charger Has 3 Selectable Voltages

The new MSP Power Supply Charger from Midtronics Inc. offers three selectable voltages of 13, 13.7, and 14.2 VDC and support for standard lead-acid, AGM (absorbent glass mat) and EFB (enhanced flooded battery) batteries.


Point S Enters the Philippines

Point S Development has signed a franchise agreement in the Philippines as part of its ongoing push to spread its banner throughout Asia.

Atturo is the official sponsor of the Chicago Wolves AHL hockey team, and the tire company's logo is featured prominently along the ice.

Atturo Sponsors the Chicago Wolves Hockey Team

Atturo Tire Corp. says its tires feel at home on the ice, so sponsoring the Chicago Wolves American Hockey League (AHL) franchise is a good fit. On St. Patrick's Day, the tire company turned up its sponsorship a notch with a special promotion.

Be the First to Know

Get the latest news and most popular articles from MTD delivered straight to your inbox. Stay on top of the tire industry and don't miss a thing!