Mano a Mano: Michelin and Continental Battle It Out in the Latest Consumer Reports Tire Testing

Bob Ulrich
Posted on October 23, 2017

Every year, Consumer Reports (CR) tests tires for its November issue. All-season tires and winter tires have been favored in the past, but this year, the tire testers went all out, testing tires in seven all-season segments and three winter tire segments. Gene Petersen, Jennifer Stockburger and Ryan Pszczolkowski outdid themselves this year!

And that’s not all: CR also re-ran survey results ranking the most and least satisfying tire retailers! It’s a milestone issue, if you ask me.

So, which brand is the big winner in this year’s series of non-winter tire tests, seven in all? There were really two. Michelin, as always, fared well, with five top finishes, including ties. But Continental tire came out on top in four of seven categories – and was a podium finisher in two of the other three.

All-season light truck tires:

1. Continental CrossContact LX20 EcoPlus.

2. Michelin Premier LTX.

3. (Tie) Firestone Destination LE 2, Pirelli Scorpion Verde All Season Plus, Michelin Defender LTX M/S.

All-terrain light truck tires:

1. (Tie) Continental TerrainContact A/T, Michelin LTX A/T 2.

3. (Tie) Goodyear Wrangler Trailrunner AT, Yokohama Geolandar A/T G015, Nexen Roadian AT Pro RA8, Falken WildPeak A/T AT3W.

Performance all-season (H-rated):

1. (Tie) Continental PureContact, Pirelli Cinturato P7 All Season Plus, Michelin Premier A/S.

Performance all-season (V-rated):

1. (Tie) Continental PureContact, Michelin Premier A/S, Pirelli Cinturato P7 All Season Plus.

Michelin had two first-place finishes by itself. The Michelin Defender was the top all-season car tire, followed by the Continental TrueContact. Tied for third was the General Altimax RT43 and Pirelli P4 Four Seasons Plus. And the Michelin Pilot Sport A/S 3+ was the number one ultra-high performance all-season tire, with two tires, the Pirelli PZero All Season Plus and the Continental ExtremeContact DWS06, tied for second.

Goodyear made a strong showing in the All-season CUV/SUV category. The Assurance CS Fuel Max was number one, followed by a three-way tie for second: Kumho Crugen Premium, Bridgestone Dueler H/L 422 Ecopia and Sumitomo HTR Enhance C/X.

CR officially recommended all the aforementioned tires to its readers.

The rankings were as objective as possible. CR ranked each tire based on nine performance attributes. The ratings ranged from Excellent to Poor.

Out of the 92 tires tested, only three received three excellents: the Nokian WR G3 SUV (hydroplaning traction, snow traction and low rolling resistance) in the all-season light truck category; and the Pirelli PZero All Season Plus (handling, hydroplaning traction and noise comfort) and Dunlop Signature HP (dry braking, handling and hydroplaning traction) in the UHP all-season category. That just goes to show you how many good tires are out there.

 For more information on the link between Consumer Reports and independent tire dealers, check out this article: "The Consumer Reports report: Tire dealers were curious about how CR ran its tire tests. MTD brought them together."

Related Topics: B.O.B., Consumer Reports, Continental CrossContact LX20 EcoPlus, Continental PureContact, Continental TerrainContact A/T, Gene Petersen, Goodyear Assurance CS Fuel Max, Jennifer Stockburger, Michelin Defender, Michelin LTX A/T 2, Michelin Pilot Sport A/S 3+, Michelin Premier A/S, Pirelli Cinturato P7 All Season Plus, Ryan Pszczolkowski

Bob Ulrich Editor
Comments ( 1 )
  • FJU

     | about 4 months ago

    In my experience with Mercedes vehicles, Continentals wear out far more quickly than the tread rating would indicate, and they are prone to bubbling on the sidewall which then requires replacement. I also found Michelins, when comparing competing tires, always had better snow traction in an all season tire.

More Stories
This Lamborghini is among the many Pirelli fitments on display at the 88th Geneva Motor Show.

Pirelli Puts on a Show in Geneva

It's a bit of an understatement to say Pirelli & Cie SpA likes the Geneva International Motor Show. Pirelli tires are installed on 60% of the prestige cars at the show, as well as a quarter of the premium vehicles.  

“It’s awesome to be going to Martinsville with Ricky and this group of guys,” said Peters.

Ricky Benton Racing Pairs With Peters For NCWTS At Martinsville

Ricky Benton Racing (RBR) Enterprises announced today that veteran Timothy Peters will be behind the wheel when the team makes its NASCAR Camping World Truck Series (NCWTS) return at Martinsville Speedway for the Alpha Energy Solutions 250 on March 24.

Alex Baron in his No. 19 Swan-RJB Motorsports racer during the Grand Prix of St. Petersburg.

Baron Marks USF2000 Return With Emphatic Win

Alexandre “Alex” Baron marked his return with the new Swan-RJB Motorsports team by scoring an impressive victory from the pole in Sunday’s Cooper Tires USF2000 Grand Prix of St. Petersburg Presented by Allied Building Products.


Urrutia Grasps His Opportunity To Win

An at-times bizarre weekend on the streets of St. Petersburg ended with popular Uruguayan Santiago “Santi” Urrutia and Belardi Auto Racing claiming a clear victory in Sunday’s Mazda Grand Prix of  St. Petersburg Presented by Cooper Tires.

Be the First to Know

Get the latest news and most popular articles from MTD delivered straight to your inbox. Stay on top of the tire industry and don't miss a thing!