Commercial Business

USW Appeals the Decision Not to Impose Tariffs on Chinese Truck Tires

Posted on April 17, 2017

The decision by the International Trade Commission (ITC), by a vote of 3-2, not to impose tariffs on truck and bus tires manufactured in China and imported into the U.S. is being appealed.

The United Steelworkers union has filed a lawsuit appealing the International Trade Commission's decision not to impose tariffs on truck and bus tires from China.
The United Steelworkers union has filed a lawsuit appealing the International Trade Commission's decision not to impose tariffs on truck and bus tires from China.
The United Steel, Paper and Forestry, Rubber, Manufacturing, Energy, Allied Industrial and Service Workers International Union (USW) has filed a civil action challenging the ITC’s decision that the domestic truck tire industry was neither materially injured nor threatened with material injury. As a result of that decision, no antidumping or countervailing duties were assessed.

The USW's lawsuit was filed against the United States.

In its appeal, the USW broke down the ITC's findings and listed its objections to them in the following four counts.

Count one: “The Commission majority made several findings regarding the conditions of competition in the U.S. truck and bus tire market, including findings with respect to branding, tiers in the market, the importance of certain product characteristics, and purchasing factors."

*  In making its findings regarding the conditions of competition, the Commission majority did not address, or otherwise ignored, evidence that contradicted its conclusions.

* The Commission majority’s conditions of competition findings are unsupported by substantial evidence and are otherwise not in accordance with the law.

Count two: “The Commission majority found subject imports did not cause significant adverse price effects despite “pervasive” underselling by subject imports, due to certain factors the Commission determined had mitigated such underselling. The Commission majority also found that there was no price suppression or price depression by subject imports.”

* In making its findings regarding adverse price effects, the Commission majority did not address, or otherwise ignored, evidence that contradicted its conclusions.

* The Commission majority also relied in part on its negative findings regarding price depression and suppression in order to support its determination that underselling was not significant, contrary to law.

* The Commission majority’s determination that subject imports did not cause significant adverse price effects is unsupported by substantial evidence and is otherwise not in accordance with the law.

Count three: “The Commission majority found that subject imports did not have a significant impact on the domestic industry, based on a number of conclusions, including findings regarding the impact of subject imports on prices, trends in the domestic industry’s operations and performance, and the production capacity of the domestic industry.”

* In making its findings regarding material injury, the Commission majority did not address, or otherwise ignored, evidence that contradicted its conclusions.

* In addition, the Commission failed to adequately explain how its conclusions regarding the operations and performance of the domestic industry complied with the statutory prohibition on reaching a negative material injury determination merely because the domestic industry is profitable or because the performance of that industry has recently improved.

* The Commission majority’s determination that the domestic industry was not materially injured by subject imports is unsupported by substantial evidence and is otherwise not in accordance with the law.

Count four: “The Commission majority found that the domestic industry was not threatened with material injury by reason of subject imports, relying heavily on its negative present material injury findings.”

* In making its findings regarding the threat of material injury, the Commission majority did not address, or otherwise ignored, evidence that contradicted its conclusions.

* The Commission majority’s determination that the domestic industry was not threatened with material injury by subject imports is unsupported by substantial evidence and is otherwise not in accordance with the law.

In its brief, the USW wrote it “respectfully requests that this Honorable Court enter judgment in favor of Plaintiff, hold that the Commission’s Final Determination is unsupported by substantial evidence and otherwise not in accordance with law, and remand the Final Determination with instructions to issue a new determination that is consistent with the Court’s decision.” The USW further requested the Court promptly provide such other relief as is just and proper.

For more information on the ITC's decision, visit "Update: No Tariffs Will Be Assessed on Truck and Bus Tires from China."

Related Topics: Chinese tire tariffs, DOC, ITC, lawsuit, TBR tariff, USW

Comments ( 1 )
  • charles

     | about 2 months ago

    bunch of babies. you lost the case .. you won on Passenger & LT..... stop protecting the unions and think of the US Consumer for once..

More Stories
News

Bauer Built Awards $6,000 in Annual Scholarships

Since 1994 Bauer Built Inc. has recognized the children and grandchildren of its employees through the G. F. “Sam” and Ethel V. Bauer/Bauer Built Inc. Scholarship program. Four high school seniors have earned the prize in 2017.

News

Titan's Union Workers Approve New Contract

United Steelworkers (USW) members working at Titan International Inc. plants in Des Moines, Iowa, Freeport, Ill. and Bryan, Ohio have ratified a new five-year contract.

The Bridgestone Europe headquarters in Zaventem.
Article

Bridgestone in Europe! Building on Continued Success

As I am sure all MTD readers can appreciate, Europe is currently in the grip of a number of significant business trading changes including a fluctuating economy and the very real prospect of the UK market eventually leaving the European Union.

Article

Cost Pressures Will Likely Continue to Build

According to the results of our survey, demand for passenger and light truck replacement tires declined in March. Indeed, from a volume standpoint, the dealers reported they sold 0.8% fewer tires in March relative to the previous year’s period. The decline marks the third straight month of poor results versus the prior year’s period. However, on more a positive note, trends improved sequentially.

ATD's new mixing center is delivering tires to 32 distribution centers. The first truck load of tires pulled out of the dock on May 1.
News

New ATD Mixing Center Has Capacity for Almost 1 Million Tires

American Tire Distributors Inc. (ATD) has opened its fourth regional mixing center in the U.S. Large enough to hold nearly 1 million tires, the mixing center in the Dallas/Fort Worth area will replenish the inventories of 32 ATD distribution centers in the Southwest.

TRMG advises selecting the appropriate repair unit, either a one- or two-piece repair, based on repair material manufacturer recommendations. “For injuries with an angle greater than 25 degrees, depending on repair manufacturer, use a two-piece repair unit system.”
Article

LT Tire Repair: TRMG Revises its Recommendations

The Tread Rubber and Tire Repair Materials Manufacturers Group (TRMG) has released additional Recommended Practices (RPs) for retreading and repairing through the Tire Retread & Repair Information Bureau (TRIB) website. The RPs are free to view on TRIB’s website, www.retread.org.

News

ASA Releases Next-Generation TireMaster Software

ASA Automotive Systems Inc. has introduced its latest software for the North American market. New TireMasterGTX is point-of-sale and accounting software for mid-sized and enterprise-level retail/wholesale businesses.

News

Pep Boys Acquires 12 Tire Stores in Memphis

Pep Boys — Manny, Moe & Jack has acquired 12 retail tire locations in the Memphis area with the purchase of Mathis Tire & Auto Service Inc. and Direct Tire Distributors Inc.

Goodyear's Wingfoot logo will appear on Kyrie Irving's jersey, as well as the rest of his Cleveland Cavaliers teammates beginning with the 2017-2018 season.
News

Goodyear Goes 'All In' With Patch on Cleveland Cavaliers Jersey

Goodyear Tire & Rubber Co. is among the first companies in the country to buy an advertisement on the jersey of a NBA team. Akron-based Goodyear made it a 'local' transaction, and announced a multi-year sponsorship agreement with the Cleveland Cavaliers.

News

Yokohama’s Sales and Earnings Increase in 1Q

Yokohama Rubber Co. Ltd. reported net income of 5.7 billion yen on net sales of 147.7 billion yen for its first quarter ended March 31, 2017. That compares to income of 3.6 billion yen on sales of 129.3 billion yen for 2016’s first quarter.

In less than a year and a half, the FBI estimated small businesses in the U.S. lost more than $75 million in downtime due to ransomware.
News

How to Protect Your Business From Ransomware

A worldwide ransomware cyberattack affected businesses, governments and personal computers in 150 countries on Friday. And while Modern Tire Dealer doesn’t claim to be clairvoyant, our April cover story on ransomware has the information you need to protect your business.

Be the First to Know

Get the latest news and most popular articles from MTD delivered straight to your inbox. Stay on top of the tire industry and don't miss a thing!