No debris debate: Don't legislate retreads

Bob Ulrich
Posted on March 25, 2009

Are retreads the cause of rubber on the road? Those of us in the industry know that a properly retreaded tire will not fail simply because it is retreaded. And we understand their importance.

So, when a government agency or newspaper editorial or letter to the editor advocates legislation because “all those retreads on the side of the road are a danger to the driving public,” we write them off because the people behind the complaining are no doubt uninformed. Retreaded tires often fail for the same reasons that new tires fail: They are run underinflated, or were damaged by a road hazard, or were serviced improperly.

How do we know? Through experience and empirical research, the latter undertaken by transportation companies or organizations. At least that’s what we tell ourselves.
A new independent report commissioned by the National Highway Traffic Safety Administration (NHTSA), however, backs up our claims. At 214 pages, the “Commercial Medium Tire Debris Study” is a comprehensive analysis of what causes rubber on the road. It answers our initial question with a resounding “No.”

The study had multiple purposes, but two stand out: to investigate why medium and heavy truck tires fail, and determine the extent of failures for retreaded truck tires.

There have been at least five studies over the last 14 years that have touched on these objectives, but they have either been regional in scope or industry-based.

This one covered almost all the bases, starting with 86,000 pounds of tire debris and casings — the equivalent of more than 700 conventional medium truck tires. They were collected in the summer of 2007 across the country at designated stretches of highway and truck stops.

After weeding out any passenger and light truck debris and unusable samples, the authors were left with a more than representative amount of rubber on the road. The casings and debris were then analyzed to determine why they failed. The key failure categories were:

1. “Over-deflected operation,” which is primarily caused by under-inflation, overloading or a combination of the two. Tires were put in this category if the failure was related to flex.

2. Excessive heat.

3. Road hazard.

4. Maintenance/operational, which includes improper tire repair, excessive wear, damage in the mounting/demounting process and driver or vehicle operation.

5. Manufacturing/process issues.

6. Other (excessive intra-carcass pressurization). “Other” failures, which are often themselves caused by failures listed in the other categories, were minimal.

The results were as expected. In order, the top three reasons that the casings were taken out of service were road hazard damage, improper maintenance and under-inflation/overloading. They represented 76% of the failures.

The top three probable causes for failure of the fragments were road hazards, excessive heat and improper maintenance. They accounted for 83% of the failures.

When new tire casings and debris are compared to retreaded casings and debris, the failure rates are similar.

It seems like every segment of the industry was involved in the study. The authors were assisted by, among others, five state departments of transportation, Bridgestone Americas Inc., the Rubber Manufacturers Association, Smithers Scientific Services Inc., and the Tire Retread and Repair Information Bureau.

Two tire dealers also were involved: Belle Tire Distributors and Shrader Tire and Oil.

The only problem I had with the study was this statement: “The proportion of tire debris from retread tires and (new) tires is similar to the estimate proportion of retread and OE tires in service.”

Based on the percentage of new truck tires shipped and retreaded in the U.S. from 1998-2007, nearly 57% were new original equipment or replacement tires. Retreads represented 43.2%.

However, close to 68% of all the truck tire debris in the “Commercial Medium Tire Debris Study” was from retreads. Comparable results can be found in the other surveys.

Even if you take into account inconsistencies among retreaders across the country, and the predominance of retreads on trailers, the numbers still don’t match. Even if some of the OE tires are sitting on new trucks and trailers that aren’t selling, shipments over a 10-year period should factor that out.

But this minor discrepancy doesn’t change the findings of the study, which support the safety of retreaded tires, and discount the need for legislation. ■

Related Topics: casings, retreaded, retreads, rubber on the road

Bob Ulrich Editor, Retired
Comments ( 1 )
  • Rob Hennon

     | about 4 years ago

    So you're telling me that the large pieces of tires that I see all over our roads and pose a danger to all drivers of passenger vehicles and even a larger danger to motorcyclists are from both NEW and RETREAD tires. I don't believe you for a minute. You're manipulating the numbers to keep the big buck retreading industry and all those who use these dangerous tires for "savings" from losing their cash cow !!! I've been injured on a cycle from these tread pieces flying up at me and I've had two different incidences where large pieces of tread badly damaged the front of my expensive vehicle and almost caused a bad accident behind me. If I were king for a day this industry would NOT EXIST ! Tell me again who is responsible for the huge amount of dangerous tread on the road that can damage cars, cause accidents and even kill people ! Stop the lies and get real .... the NEW tires are not peeling back in huge hunks, it's the RETREADS !

More Stories

Goodyear Unveils New Brand Campaign

Goodyear Tire & Rubber Co. says its new  brand campaign “underscores its more than 120-year commitment to the discovery, growth and possibility that is fueled by mobility.”

Figure 3: An exploded view of the tire pressure sensor assembly.

TPMS: Buick Regal, 2011-2019, and Verano, 2012-2017

The tire pressure monitoring system (TPMS) in the 2011-2019 Buick Regal and 2012-2017 Verano uses the instrument panel cluster (IPC), body control module (BCM), 4 radio frequency transmitting pressure sensors, and the serial data circuit to perform the TPMS relearn mode functions.


Goodyear Records $399 Million Profit Loss in 4Q 2019

The final months of 2019 delivered a painful blow to Goodyear Tire & Rubber Co., as the tiremaker recorded a net loss of $399 million in the fourth quarter, and a loss of $297 million for the full year.


Michelin Boosted Income, Sales in 2019

Groupe Michelin achieved segment operating income of slightly more than three billion euros on overall, global sales of 24.1 billion euros during 2019.

Grismer Tire Co. works with local high schools and community colleges to recruit young service techs. That’s how Jeremiah Johnson (pictured) was introduced to the dealership.

Tackling the Technician Shortage

"Good help is hard to find.” Have you been muttering these words under your breath a lot lately? Maybe you’ve been shouting them from the rooftop of your stores?

Mavis Discount Tire is adding 112 stores — NTB outlets currently owned by TBC Corp. — to its portfolio. The stores are located in Philadelphia, Boston, Atlanta and Chicago.

Mavis Will Acquire 112 NTB Stores

Mavis Tire Supply Co. is buying 112 NTB Tire & Service Centers, a move that will make it the second largest independent tire dealer in the U.S.

Rob Slagle says maintaining a team of technicians and offering a full menu of automotive services are key to the success of his dealership. “Auto repair is a profitable part of our business.”

One Dealer’s Search for Technicians

One day, Rob Slagle is pitching the automotive trade to kindergarten students during a school job fair. A few months later, his tire dealership is the first in the country to partner with Universal Technical Institute Inc. (UTI) in a new program designed to assign post-secondary students to workplaces for hands-on training.

Be the First to Know

Get the latest news and most popular articles from MTD delivered straight to your inbox. Stay on top of the tire industry and don't miss a thing!

We respect your data and privacy.
By clicking the submit button below, you are agreeing with Bobit Business Media’s Privacy Policy and this outlined level of consent.