Follow Your Gut Instinct: Advice From Our Tire Dealer of the Year

Joy Kopcha
Posted on October 27, 2016
Putting the right tires on the right vehicle is like dressing up in a tuxedo, says Barbara, left, with his store manager, Denny Reiser. “You can dress up in a tuxedo and wear black tennis shoes and still look OK, but try to go out on the dance floor. You’re not going to be able to do it.”
Putting the right tires on the right vehicle is like dressing up in a tuxedo, says Barbara, left, with his store manager, Denny Reiser. “You can dress up in a tuxedo and wear black tennis shoes and still look OK, but try to go out on the dance floor. You’re not going to be able to do it.”

When a customer walks in convinced his car doesn’t need synthetic motor oil when you think it does, and argues with you at every suggestion, do you take the time to educate him and explain your recommendation? Do you turn down the job? Or do you take his money, use traditional oil, and hope for the best?

It’s a gut check. And there may be dozens of moments like that every week in a tire dealership.

I didn’t ask Alpio Barbara, our 2016 Tire Dealer of the Year, to give me his philosophy on business, but I didn’t have to. After spending two-and-a-half days with him and his team at Redwood General Tire Service Co., it was clear. “I’ll sell a product if I believe in it,” he says.

That means he sells road hazard warranties, and says it’s one of the big benefits of his membership in the Tire Pros network. “It keeps bringing the customer back.” If the customer is far from home, one phone call to a toll-free number connects the customer to another independent dealer who will take care of the problem. That’s not an add-on charge that pads the bill. That’s customer service.

In many instances, it’s the flip side of Barbara’s rule that guides the process. He doesn’t fill tires with nitrogen. “I think nitrogen works well on airplanes. I think nitrogen works well in NASCAR. I’m not so sure we need nitrogen on our everyday cars that we drive.” He’s had colleagues ask, “What’s wrong with you? You can get $6 a tire and make $24 for your bottom line.” But he holds firm. “I’m not going to do it because it’s a profit center for me because I don’t believe in it.”

Quick oil change service? Tested it and abandoned it because he didn’t like putting cars back on the road with worn brakes because the customer only wanted an oil change. “There’s a time and a purpose for a quick change and dedicated bays,” Barbara says, but that’s not the kind of business he wants to operate. Redwood General Tire conducts a 72-point inspection on every vehicle. His technicians replace burned-out taillights and tell the customer after the fact.

He doesn’t believe in advertisements with tiny print. “You can’t do a $9.95 oil change. You can’t do a smog test for $29.95 when you’re paying your technician $30,” Barbara says. “If you’re going to do a smog test the proper way, it takes a good 35 minutes. How can you make any money on that? We’re not a church.

“I don’t want to put pressure on my salesman, ‘OK the price is $9.95, but by the time the customer leaves I want you to get $85 out of them.’ That’s not ethical. That’s not right.”

Barbara sees plenty of people following a different path, tire dealers and tire manufacturers included. “Our trouble is people in our own industry; they’ll do anything to make a sale. They’ll put any brand of tire on to make a sale, and they’ll put any brake on to make a sale.”

He doesn’t lead his team to selling a certain brand of tire. He and Store Manager Denny Reiser talk constantly about how every transaction needs to be a win, win, win. “You should be free to do what is right,” Reiser says. “There is a way the customer can win, the salesman can win, and the store can make money and win.”

Sometimes, they are small wins, like the customer who didn’t want the synthetic oil. Barbara’s salesman convinced him otherwise. And the customer paid the ticket without complaint.

If you have comments or questions, email Senior Editor Joy Kopcha at

Please see Alpio Barbara's store here:

One Man. One Superstore: Alpio Barbara's Employees Call Him a Commanding, Charismatic Leader. We Call Him Our 2016 Tire Dealer of the Year

Related Topics: 2016 Tire Dealer of the Year, Alpio Barbara, Joy Kopcha, MTD Tire Dealer of the Year

Joy Kopcha Senior Editor & Digital Projects Editor
Comments ( 0 )
More Stories

Monro Will Accept Wex Fleet Cards

The 1,100-plus Monro Inc. locations in the U.S. will accept Wex Inc. fleet cards for payment. Those cards are used by 11.5 million vehicles.


Max Finkelstein Adds Falken and Ohtsu Brands

Max Finkelstein Inc. (MFI) is partnering with Falken Tire Corp. to distribute Falken and Ohtsu brand passenger and light truck tires throughout the Mid-Atlantic and Northeast U.S. 

Consumers will receive “Save the Tiger” kits when they buy Uniroyal tires in October.

Uniroyal Wants to Save Tigers in the Wild

Three years ago, Uniroyal dealers told Michelin North America Inc. the Uniroyal brand needed to be strengthened and refreshed. Based on the feedback, Michelin started a series of initiatives that have come to fruition this year.


Hankook Relies on OE Tires for 2Q Sales Growth

Hankook Tire Corp. Ltd. posted net sales of 1.7 trillion won for the second quarter ended June 30, 2018. That compares to sales of 1.66 trillion won for the same period in fiscal 2017.


Versatile Credit Adds EasyPay Finance Option

Versatile Credit Inc. has added the EasyPay Finance option to its list of platform offerings. The "second look" option focuses on offering financing solutions to the automotive market.


Unit Sales Volumes Were Up Nearly 2%

Our recent discussions with dealers leave us with a view that sell-out trends improved in May versus the prior year’s period, re-accelerating from year-over-year contractions early in the year. While always somewhat subjective, we note commentary from installers was at the highest level since October 2017. From a volume standpoint, surveyed dealers reported they saw unit sales volumes up nearly 2% relative to the previous year’s period.

Be the First to Know

Get the latest news and most popular articles from MTD delivered straight to your inbox. Stay on top of the tire industry and don't miss a thing!