Tire Pricing Strategy: Why You Shouldn’t Play the Match Game

Mike Townsend
Posted on August 2, 2018

When Mavis Tire Supply Corp. purchased the Sun Tire and Automotive Services chain in March, it put the scare into one of my customers. “Competition has never been greater, especially for the small dealer,” he said. “The big are getting bigger. I feel like an island, with fewer options.”

It seems that change is in the air. Merger mania on both the retail and wholesale side continues to happen, with Mavis, Monro Inc. and now Goodyear Tire and Rubber Co. and Bridgestone Americas Inc. (with their TireHub joint venture) the most aggressive players at the moment.

Many tire retailers feel like they are being surrounded and vulnerable to how others may try to beat them with lower prices, rebates and sales gimmicks.

With the proper phone skills, most front counter salespeople can sell tires for up to $80 to $100 more per set. Many times this comes down to how you make the customer feel on the phone.
With the proper phone skills, most front counter salespeople can sell tires for up to $80 to $100 more per set. Many times this comes down to how you make the customer feel on the phone.
Even though tire dealers need to be aware of what is going on in the market, they have to think about what they can control and not worry about what their competitors are doing or not doing.

Many times the worry comes from a lack of pricing strategy. For example, we were working with a multi-store dealer recently, and found his price for a popular LT size was almost $40 per unit lower than his nearest competitor.

Some dealers are afraid to increase their prices against the low-cost leaders when they should be optimistically cautious. With the proper phone skills, most front counter salespeople can sell tires for up to $80 to $100 more per set. Many times this comes down to how you make the customer feel on the phone. Those feelings include:

  • how you communicate integrity (they will trust you more),
  • how you communicate value (they will feel they are getting more value), and
  • how they feel about your team (the more professional your staff, the better information flows in your dealership -- and they will notice).

How you make a customer feel is now called Customer Experience and involves making your customer feel served and never sold. Of course, engaging customers in a meaningful way on the phone and accomplishing this does not happen overnight. Salespeople who try to sell to customers turn off a larger percentage versus those salespeople who offer the customer multiple choices and then ask the customer, “Which one would you like to choose for your car?”

I have noticed that there are too many “I would like to sell you” salespeople, which has given the online retailers a huge niche. Online retailers have taken the trust of another human out of the equation and helped commoditize tire sales as well as other products.

Fallacies of price matching

We have found that when customers mention they can find a lower price elsewhere, they are indirectly telling your salespeople, “I want to do business with you, but you have to make me feel like I am getting a better value.” Many consumers understand that if the dealership has the lowest price, it may very well sacrifice in others areas, such as service.

As for value, I notice many dealers do not list on the bill the services that the customer either receives for free or at a discounted rate. To get full credit for this “value,” set up your invoices accordingly.

Proof that building value will work

Several years ago Subway only had one competitor: Quiznos.

Quiznos started matching price but did not lower quality. It could have kept its higher price by holding its ground and communicating that it was better because of better ingredients, therefore building value (i.e., “We cost more because we taste better”).

Here’s proof of the validity of the higher price theory: After Quiznos virtually dissolved, many competitors filled the niche that was left (Firehouse Subs, Jimmy John’s, Jersey Mike’s), and none of them are close in price to a $5 footlong offered by Subway. — Mike Townsend

If the potential customers did not want to patronize your store, they would not challenge your price. They would say something like, “I will let you know soon.”

A professional salesperson knows the capabilities of all his or her competitors, and knows how to properly sow seeds of doubt against them without ever mentioning their names. They also know how to avoid negotiating tire price or worse, in my opinion, matching price.

Below are eight reasons why allowing your salespeople to negotiate and/or price match on a tire sale is a bad idea.

  1. It greatly reduces the profits of your store.
  2. It encourages your salespeople to be order takers.
  3. If it is negotiable, many customers will perceive you as less than trustworthy.
  4. Women rate price lower than being locally owned as a reason to buy -- as long as you can communicate value.
  5. Price matching communicates that your price is already too high.
  6. Price matching also encourages a potential customer to shop your competitors.
  7. You are falsely assuming the customer will not buy value.
  8. It makes it virtually impossible to employ and keep professional salespeople.

The professional salesperson of today needs to be equipped with multiple processes, phone skills, and know how to make customers feel like they are getting the best value by coming to your store compared to your competitor. Even though it is not easy to overcome when a prospect challenges your price, it is possible to win more than you lose while keeping your margin on the tire sale.

For more information on how to overcome competitors that lead on price, download our free e-book at ■

Mike Townsend is owner of Townsend Strategies, a sales and leadership training and marketing firm. He has nearly 30 years of sales experience, 13 of them in the tire industry. As a Six Sigma black belt and professional trainer, Townsend says he “has witnessed every scenario and heard every objection in the retail tire environment across every state in the U.S.” For more information, call (865) 318-4588 or (800) 319-8552, or email Townsend at

Related Topics: competition, customer service, Mike Townsend, Phone etiquette, retail, Telephone etiquette, tire pricing

Comments ( 1 )
  • Neto

     | about 7 months ago

    This article has both good and bad advice. While I agree with the author about price matching 100%. This topic sound great in theory, but is not practical. Lets face it. Tires have become nothing more then a commodity. Price trumps value to most customers because distributors and manufactures rather whore out products to every kid with a lemon aid stand then actually find dealers that can sell on value. Many customers are going to shop the market both locally and online for who is the lowest to buy from; regardless if I price match or not. As the writer states: "It greatly reduces the profits of your store" that statement only leads around the true problem. That is only if their was great profits to begin with. The profit margins for retail tires are shameful to begin with. At least with price match gives you a fighting chance in an industry filled with whores.

More Stories

Les Schwab No Longer Holds Exclusive Rights to Toyo in Northwest U.S.

For 52 years Les Schwab Tire Centers Inc. had an exclusive, multi-state territory with Toyo Tire USA Corp. That deal, which effectively locked out other tire dealers, including online retailers, from selling Toyo-branded products in the northwest corner of the U.S. has come to an end.  


Tenneco Spin-Off to be Called DRiV Incorporated

DRiV Incorporated is the name of the future publicly traded aftermarket and ride performance company that will launch in the second half of this year, following Tenneco Inc.’s separation into two independent companies, Tenneco has announced.


Yokohama's 2018 Earnings Fall on Slightly Higher Sales

Yokohama Rubber Co. Ltd. posted net income of 35.6 billion yen on net sales of 650.2 billion yen for the fiscal year ended December 31, 2018. That compares to income of 40.0 billion yen on sales of 646.3 billion yen in fiscal 2017.


Hercules Partners with Another UTV Racing Team

Hercules Tire and Rubber Co. has finalized another partnership with a prominent racing team owner. Will Rodgers and Rodgers Racing will begin competing on Hercules tires in March.

Affleck was the first president of Big O, a position he held for 25 years.

Norm Affleck, a Founding Member of Big O, Dies

Norm Affleck, retired CEO and president of Big O Tires Inc., died on Feb. 8, 2019. He was not only a founding dealer member of Big O Tires, but also instrumental in the introduction of the Big O brand 33 years ago.


Independents vs. Conglomerates: Who’s Winning the Battle for Tire-Buying Consumers?

It seems like every issue of Modern Tire Dealer has an announcement of a new acquisition by Monro Inc., Icahn Automotive Group LLC, Bridgestone Americas Inc. and the like. One would assume by reading these that what I call the company-owned conglomerates are “winning the war” for the hearts and minds of consumers, but I would disagree. I think tire dealers are winning right now.


Benchmarks Are Not a Myth

A gross profit benchmark of 60% for a tire store is not a myth. Dennis McCarron explains how to reach it, from setting your shop’s labor rates to getting 50% margins on your parts sales.  

Be the First to Know

Get the latest news and most popular articles from MTD delivered straight to your inbox. Stay on top of the tire industry and don't miss a thing!