Retail

Acquiring Controlled Distribution Aids Brand Share Growth

Michael McGregor
Posted on February 21, 2019

Here’s a little history lesson for the young people. Bridgestone Corp. was not always the largest tire company in the world. The acquisition of Firestone Tire & Rubber Co. in 1988 helped make it the largest.

Initially, the deal did not include the Firestone stores, but to outbid a combined offer from Pirelli & Cie SpA and Groupe Michelin, Bridgestone upped its offer and had to take the stores as well as the factories. Once viewed as an afterthought, the stores would eventually help make Bridgestone the market share leader.

I’m a big believer in acquiring controlled distribution as a business strategy. Controlled distribution allows a manufacturer to push what it wants both where it wants and when it wants. And it allows that manufacturer to capture the extra margin that exists between 1) the manufacturer to the distributor, 2) the distributor to the store and 3) the store to the consumer.

Business is tough today. It’s nice to have multiple reasons to be in any industry. Controlled distribution offers manufacturers multiple, profitable reasons, and Bridgestone is the best example of how well this can work.

In looking at the U.S. replacement passenger tire market share in 1988, industry leader Goodyear Tire & Rubber Co. held a 16% share with its Goodyear brand alone, versus 10.5% for a combined Bridgestone brand (2%) and Firestone brand (8.5%). Thirty years later that has flipped.

The chart below illustrates the change in each company’s store count over the same time period. I believe it’s no coincidence Bridgestone’s market share went up as its company-owned store count — aka controlled distribution — increased, while Goodyear’s brand share decreased as its store count dropped significantly. Goodyear’ share is now 12%, while Bridgestone and Firestone are a combined 14% with 7% each. Bridgestone/Firestone’s profit also improved over time as the mix shifted in the stores to higher ticket, higher margin Bridgestone product.

Undertaking this is not for the lighthearted. Bridgestone had to learn how to manage channel conflict, and the key person they chose to do this was tire industry legend John Gamauf, who got his start in those Firestone stores. Gamauf created the Affiliated Dealer program, which became part of the “family channel” in which certain “fighting products” like Dayton, Road King and Peerless were dedicated to the dealers and Triumph and Lemans went to the stores. Next, he created area-marketing rules that applied in metro and rural markets for existing and new locations and a conflict resolution methodology for when problems arose.

Additionally, greater support was given to dealers who committed to a greater in-house share of Bridgestone/Firestone product and followed the rules he laid out. All these programs evolved over time, but Gamauf showed how a manufacturer could grow its dealer base and volume while also expanding its company-owned store count.

Icahn Automotive Group LLC appears to be trying to do the same thing with parts. It sold Federal-Mogul LLC to parts manufacturer Tenneco Inc. for money and stock in Tenneco. The group also owns the Auto Plus and Pep Boys-Manny, Moe & Jack parts distribution chains, and serves the end consumer through the various service outlets it has acquired, including Pep Boys, Just Brakes, AAMCO, Cottman and Precision Tune outlets and other tire dealers it has acquired.

Icahn’s mix of retail brands looks to me like a hodgepodge. I can’t imagine that Just Brakes, Precision Tune or AAMCO/Cottman do any sort of meaningful sales volume at retail. I think Icahn Automotive is better off acquiring the eight to 10 bay tire dealers and larger auto service facilities like its acquisitions of Advanced Auto & Tire in Phoenix and Mathis Tire in Memphis. I would not be surprised to see some of those other brands spun out again at some point.

Like Icahn Automotive, TBC Corp. has a collection of company-owned outlets and franchise operations. I’m not privy to its financials, but I’ll bet you the company-owned outlets like NTB sell more tires, but the franchising operations make more money.

If controlled distribution is part of the plan, it has to be a long-term play. Having experienced, high-volume tire and service operators running the stores is one key to success. Keeping that experienced team in place over many years is the next key toward continuous improvement. And investing in the business and new opportunities as they arise will help increase brand market share. ■

Michael McGregor is a veteran of the tire and service industry and a partner at Focus Investment Banking LLC (focusbankers.com/tire-and-service). He advises and assists multi-location tire dealers on mergers and acquisitions in the auto aftermarket. For more information contact him at michael.mcgregor@focusbankers.com.

Related Topics: mergers and acquisitions, Michael McGregor, retail

Comments ( 3 )
  • See all comments
  • CRAIG WALTER

     | about 7 months ago

    For some folks, we wonder why Firestone sold in the first place. Some of us have been around for a while and might even know. I couldn't find that in your article.

More Stories
T.J. Trum
News

TIA Elects 4 Tire Dealers to Board

The Tire Industry Association (TIA) has elected five members to its board of directors — including four representing tire dealerships.

News

Hankook Consumer Tire Promotion Kicks Off

Hankook Tire America Corp.'s Fall Classic Rebate is giving consumers a chance to receive up to a $70 prepaid Mastercard when buying a set of one of six Hankook passenger and light truck tires.

The new Toyo Extensa A/S II will be available in 55 sizes covering more than 80% of the vehicle market by the end of the first quarter of 2020.
Product

Toyo Introduces the Extensa A/S II

The new Extensa A/S II from Toyo Tire U.S.A. Corp. is a value-oriented all-season tire for passenger cars, minivans, SUVs, CUVs, and light trucks.

Schraderbundle special includes five years of tool software updates and OBDII connection capabilities.
Product

Bundle and Save with Schrader TPMS Solutions

Schrader TPMS Solutions continues to offer competitive OE-quality TPMS solutions with two bundle specials: a Schrader VT46 TPMS programming and diagnostic tool powered by ATEQ and 12 or 24 EZ-sensors, a single SKU, programmable TPMS solution.

News

ITDG Plans Regional Meetings for Dealers

Independent Tire Dealers Group LLC (ITDG) is taking its show on the road in a series of seven regional meetings designed to make it easier and less expensive for members to attend.  

Josh Lopez has been hired to manage sales in the western region of the U.S. by TPMS manufacturer Hamaton Inc.
News

Hamaton Hires Josh Lopez to Manage Western Sales

Josh Lopez is the new western regional sales manager for Hamaton Inc., the U.S. division of tire pressure monitoring system (TPMS) and valve manufacturer Hamaton Automotive Technology Co. Ltd.

Be the First to Know

Get the latest news and most popular articles from MTD delivered straight to your inbox. Stay on top of the tire industry and don't miss a thing!