Help Fleets Understand the Reasons Behind Tire Failure
It’s said that dead men tell no tales. Dead tires sure do, however. If trucking fleets ignore them, they do so at their own expense. Since tires rarely self-destruct, there is always a smoking gun, and it’s everyone’s best interest to find it and bring it to the attention of the trucking company through failure analysis.
An expert can tell at a glance what’s happening to a tire, often by just looking at it or rubbing a hand over the tread face. Tire wear, you see, isn’t the tire’s fault. There’s something wrong with the truck that’s aggravating the situation. You must fix that to arrest the tire wear. So where do you start? If the trucking company does not have the luxury of an in-house expert, a service provider can help. Jeff Lecklider, president of Gem City Tire in Dayton, Ohio, performs that service for dozens of fleet customers.
“We work with the customer to help them to reduce their tire costs, and we usually start with a fleet survey,” he says. “We’ll give them a baseline of the condition of their fleet, including tread depth, air pressure, any tire conditions, irregular wear, flat tires, etc., and then we recommend a course of action. We do this regularly so we can spot problems as soon as they become visible.”
Various mechanical problems leave telltale signs on tires. Take cupping and scalloped wear on a steer tire. That’s usually caused by some non-uniformity in the tire/wheel assembly, such as non-concentric mounting or a moderate to severe out-of-balance condition. Feathered wear on a steer tire is another easy one — it’s a sign of misalignment. But which misalignment condition?
Here you might need to dig a little deeper. It could be an excessive toe-in condition. It could be drive axle misalignment creating a side thrust. Or it could be a bent tie rod.
During, After And Before
It obviously makes sense for fleets to monitor in-service tire performance, watching for irregular wear and mechanically induced damage, but tracking wear and using that insight for future tire purchases really pays off. Tire tracking can be tedious, but it is getting easier. Most maintenance software platforms enable tire tracking, and some of the tire pressure monitoring systems offer the ability to self-populate those databases.
“On top of providing real-time tire pressure and temperature readings and alert schedules, we’re also able to provide fleets with historical performance data to unlock tire performance trends,” says Vanessa Hargrave, CMO of Advantage PressurePro. “We’re now able to help fleets move their tire maintenance programs from reactive to proactive.”
When Kirk Altrichter was vice president of maintenance at Crete Carrier Corp. (he’s now vice president of fleet services at Kenan Advantage Group), he participated in a Tire Benchmarking panel discussion at an American Trucking Associations’ Technology & Maintenance Council (TMC) meeting where he revealed some of the benefits of a diligent tracking program.
“With my supplier, we have been watching which tires fail at what wheel positions,” he said. “It was interesting but not unexpected that the right rear outer trailer was the most failure-prone position. We also found an unexpectedly high number of failures of the left rear inner tires.
“It’s all about trying to take cost out by identifying problems before they occur on the road. For the past several years we have tried to ensure we have the right tire at the right wheel position,” he added.
If staying on top of their tires while they are still on the truck is too tall an order for a trucking company, there is always the fleet yard survey, or as a last resort, an objective study of their tire scrap pile. It’s too late for that tire once it hits the scrap pile, but if they kept a record of what truck and wheel position it came from, they can still glean some insight from it.
Every type of calamity to befall a tire leaves a fingerprint. TMC Tire Condition guides can help determine the cause of the failure. It is estimated that about 80% of on-road tire failures not caused by a road hazard are the result of creeping air loss, or under-inflation. FleetNet America recently produced a maintenance benchmarking report demonstrating the difference in various maintenance practices. In the tire category, for example, results of their collected data showed that the average fleet in the survey experienced on-road tire repair/replacement events every 35,166 miles. The worst-in-class fleet put in a service call every 34,438 miles.
Astonishingly, the best-in-class fleet in the reporting group saw a service call frequency at half the rate of the worst fleet, with an event occurring only once every 71,238 miles. Those are averages, of course, but it shows pretty clearly that a bit of tire maintenance can go a really long way.
That fleet, and those like it, probably pay a lot more attention to their tires before and during their service life, rather than after.
Tire/Wheel Analysis Sources
Two of the best guides on tire wear conditions and causes available are Recommended Practice documents 216C and 219C, published by the TMC. These RP manuals are updated every few years, and there’s an updated version of RP 219, Radial Tire Wear Conditions and Causes, in the pipeline due to be published later this year.
On the wheel side, TMC offers RP 222C, A User’s Guide to Wheels and Rims. At 94 pages, this RP leaves no stone left unturned when it comes to wheel installation, fasteners, mounting, and damage and defect analysis.
Major wheel suppliers, such as Accuride, Alcoa by Arconic, and Maxion, also offer their own wheel maintenance guides.