Why Satisfying the Tire-Buying Customer Is So Vital

Bob Ulrich
Posted on March 15, 2018

There are more than 29,000 independent tire dealerships in the U.S., and I like to think they all care about satisfying the customer. But every once in a while I hear about a store manager taking advantage of a customer.

That makes me mad. Think about how hard you work to make your customers feel welcome and comfortable in your store. Just because buying tires is more often than not a necessary purchase doesn't mean it has to be a bad experience.

Tell that to my friend, who recently asked me to recommend tires for his wife's car. I've had this happen many times over the years, and I always start by saying there are a lot of reliable tire brands out there.

Then I ask questions that tell me what he or she is looking for. In this case, my friend told me his wife was scared about driving in the snow on her worn tires, especially with another nor'easter coming their way. I suggested winter tires and explained how they work in cold temperatures.

They did not want to spend the money on two sets of tires, however (sound familiar?), so I suggested all-season or all-weather tires. Off the top of my head, I thought of two new lines that emphasize a little more of the winter season/weather part of the equation, the Toyo Celsius and the Goodyear WeatherReady.

His wife went to a local independent tire dealership (I suggested that, too), which didn't have the Celsius in stock. "They told her the WeatherReady was a cheap Walmart tire, which was odd because they had a WeatherReady display in their showroom," my friend told me. "They then said it had production problems and wasn't available."

Instead the salesman -- my friend said his wife described him as having a "used car salesman" manner about him -- steered her toward an all-season line exclusive to the dealership, "a better value," he said.

Was it a better value? Maybe. It was to the salesman. It did have a 75,000-mile limited tread wear warranty versus a 60,000 for the WeatherReady for $150 a tire. But its winter capabilities were not as good. It simply wasn't what she wanted, and she left the store unhappy.

"Did we get played?" asked my friend, who was upset. I told him the tire was a good tire, and although not as good in the snow as the WeatherReady was supposed to be, was better than her current tires. In addition, what she may have given up in winter traction was somewhat balanced by the greater tread wear warranty, which, given they only wanted to buy one set of tires, was at least some compensation.

But they weren't what she wanted. She left the store disgruntled. You would have to ask her why she bought the tires anyway.

I also told my friend he should check to see if there was any sort of 30-day purchase guarantee on the tires. He decided not to make any changes.

As our conversation was ending, he told me his father needed new tires for his car. "I'm not going to take his car to the same dealer," he said.

That spoke volumes about the dealer's performance. The dealership may have made the sale, but will lose out in the long run.

Related Topics: all-season tires, B.O.B., Goodyear, Toyo Tires, winter tires

Bob Ulrich Editor
Comments ( 4 )
  • See all comments
  • Ron Kapur

     | about 7 months ago

    I agree. If the Advisor, which is what this sales guy is, should do what's best for the client. I've been in this Industry for 30+ years. I Manage a Goidyear Store. It's not always a Goidyear Tire that I install on a Clients car. You HAVE to ask questions and help them make the right decision for their lifestyle. You also have to keep in mind that their children or other friends and family also ride in this car. Same goes for selling Service items to these Clients. Training is essential. The best advise I can give is to LISTEN to what the Client is saying.

More Stories
The 2019 Porsche 911 GT3 R will make its customer racing debut this weekend in the iconic Falken Motorsport teal and blue colours.

Falken Motorsports Continues in the Fast Lane

After romping to a double victory in the last race of the VLN Endurance Championship, Falken Motorsports is now heading for the next highlight: The team of the Japanese tire manufacturer is the first customer team to provide a set of test tires for tests of the new Porsche 911 GT3 R on the Nürburgring race track.


CRC Industries and NAPA Partner to Support Service Men and Women

CRC Industries Inc. is partnering with the National Automotive Parts Association (NAPA Auto Parts) to support the Intrepid Fallen Heroes Fund (IFHF), a not-for-profit organization that serves United States military personnel suffering from traumatic brain injury (TBI) and post-traumatic stress (PTS).

Peter Derschang joins Leeds West Groups after serving as chief financial officer at Brakes Plus Corp.

Leeds West Groups Hires New CFO

Leeds West Groups (LWG) has hired Peter Derschang to serve as chief financial officer and a member of the advisory board of directors.

Earning one of these Automotive Lift Institute (ALI) gold certification labels is a little more challenging under the new edition of ANSI/ALI ALCTV now in effect.

ALI Strengthens Vehicle Lift Testing Standard

The Automotive Lift Institute’s (ALI) updated safety standard expands the third-party testing required for a vehicle lift to earn the organization’s gold certification label.

Be the First to Know

Get the latest news and most popular articles from MTD delivered straight to your inbox. Stay on top of the tire industry and don't miss a thing!