Warehouse Clubs Compete for In-Store and Online Tire Sales

Since the first of the year, the store count at Sam's Club has decreased by 63 outlets.
Since the first of the year, the store count at Sam's Club has decreased by 63 outlets.

Warehouse clubs account for 9% of the replacement consumer tire market in the U.S., according to the 2018 Modern Tire Dealer Facts Issue. In 2017, that represented 21.5 million tires.

Their growth hasn’t been as spectacular as, say, the auto dealership channel, but it has been steady, in part because overall store count has risen steadily. That may change this year.

In 2007, there were 1,147 Sam’s Club, Costco Wholesale and BJ’s Wholesale Club outlets in the U.S. Last year, there were 1,399 – a 22% increase over that 10-year span -- broken out as follows:

Wholesale club                Stores/2007     Stores/2017

Sam’s Club                         586                   660

Costco Wholesale Corp.    385                   518

BJ’s Wholesale Club Inc.   176                   221

This year, however, parent company Wal-Mart Stores Inc. has already closed 63 Sam’s Club outlets. If there are no other changes, that would be enough to drop warehouse club market share to 8.5%, the distribution channel’s first decrease since I can remember.

Up to 12 of the stores will be converted to eCommerce facilities, which will no doubt inventory tires. The need to “better fulfill online orders” was cited by USA Today and other news sources as the main reason for the changeover.

In a Sam’s Club press release, CEO and President John Furner would only say “Transforming our business means managing our real estate portfolio, and Walmart needs a strong fleet of Sam’s Clubs that are fit for the future.”

Warehouse clubs are not quick to advertise, preferring to pass those savings along to its members in the form of low prices. Both BJ’s Wholesale Club and Costco Wholesale have been advertising of late, at least in Northeast Ohio.

Full-page BJ’s advertisements in local shoppers have been promoting a membership drive geared around tire sales. “Fill up for 1-cent a gallon (up to 30 gallons) when you buy a set of 4 Michelin tires,” trumpeted the membership offer. It’s interesting that BJ’s feels Michelin tires and virtually free gas will increase its membership.

Costco ads are digitally oriented. One April email I received offered “$70 off instantly on any set of 4 Michelin tires” to members (I am not a member), plus 1 cent installation per tire ($59.96 in additional savings, according to the ad). The $70 savings was offered both online and in-store.

Maybe warehouse clubs are upping their game in the replacement tire market, especially when it comes to online sales.

Related Topics: BJ's Wholesale, Costco, MTD Facts Issue, Sam's Club, Walmart, warehouse clubs

Bob Ulrich Editor
Comments ( 1 )
  • dennis

     | about 10 months ago

    good ideas as for as the promo goes. However, they have poor employee help. Never the same guy or gal twice, cannot answer their phone (unless it is the personal cell phone) are detached and would never work in my place. It is only price driven

More Stories
Article

What Employees Get Right: Become Better at Pointing Out the Positives

It’s easy writing articles about what’s wrong with the tire and service industry. It comes naturally to most folks — picking out what others are doing wrong. We are all guilty of it. You walk out into the shop and what are you looking for? Rags or parts boxes on the floor, the car that isn’t pulled in yet, the tech without his safety glasses.

News

Bridgestone's 2018 Sales Matched 2017

Net sales for Bridgestone Corp. in fiscal 2018 were 3,650.1 billion yen, the same as the previous year; operating income was 402.7 billion yen, a decrease of 4%. Income was 381.1 billion yen, a decrease of 5%; and profits were 291.6 billion yen, an increase of 1%.

That's three CEOs for Point S on a single stage. From left, Walter Lybeck, CEO in the U.S., Christophe Rollet, CEO in France, and Fabien Bouquet, CEO of Point S International.
News

Point S Dealers Increased Sales by 10% in 2018

Point S Tire & Auto Service retailers in the U.S. have access to new tools to help them serve consumers online, manage customer feedback and pursue and track declined services. Leaders expect the tools will help Point S dealers beat the 10% increase in sales they recorded in 2018.  

Galvan has been with CMA for more than 11 years.
News

CMA Makes Organizational Changes

China Manufacturers Alliance LLC (CMA) has made three organizational changes to streamline operations and improve CMA’s overall customer experience.

Approaching brakes, ride control and tires as systems to be serviced together, not separately, helps service advisors and automotive technicians make more accurate service recommendations to their customers, say industry experts.
Article

Service Brakes, Ride Control and Tires Together to Reduce Comebacks

When it comes to diagnosing brake, ride control and tire wear issues, a new approach to the tried-and-true steps for inspecting vehicles can help boost service sales and reduce comebacks. For details, Modern Tire Dealer turned to Joe Bacarella from Tenneco Inc., manufacturer of Monroe shocks and other aftermarket products, and Dann Ingebritson from Brake Parts Inc LLC (BPI), maker of Raybestos brand brakes.

News

Goodyear Is Working on Next Gen Tire Optix

Goodyear Tire & Rubber Co.’s Tire Optix commercial tire management program was introduced in Nashville at the 2018 Goodyear Customer Conference. Nearly 1 million commercial truck tires have been inspected using the program since then.

Be the First to Know

Get the latest news and most popular articles from MTD delivered straight to your inbox. Stay on top of the tire industry and don't miss a thing!