Strandberg: Are You Talking to Other Dealers?
One of my favorite parts about writing this column has very little to do with the writing itself. It’s what happens afterward.
I get calls, emails, texts and conversations at industry events with tire dealers who want to talk about whatever we covered that month. Sometimes they agree with me. Sometimes they don’t. Often, the conversation quickly moves beyond my column entirely. An owner tells me what they’re trying in their own business, asks what I’m seeing elsewhere or shares something that worked, or didn’t.
Those conversations have become some of my favorite interactions in this industry. They’ve also made me wonder whether we need more of them.
That’s not to say tire dealers don’t communicate. There are strong associations, dealer groups, conferences and plenty of long-standing relationships throughout the industry. But as I look at what is happening in the market right now, I wonder whether the next generation of tire dealerships would benefit from even more open communication between ambitious owners because many of the questions facing a growing tire dealer today aren’t really tire questions.
When should I hire my first regional manager? At what point should I centralize accounting? How much corporate overhead should I build ahead of growth? How should I compensate my store managers? How do I recruit technicians at scale? What functions should stay at the store level and what should move to corporate? How do I integrate an acquisition without disrupting what made the acquired business successful in the first place?
Those are company-building questions. And there are tire dealers across the country trying to answer them at the same time. Imagine putting 10 ambitious tire dealers from noncompeting markets around a table. One has figured out technician recruiting. Another has built a great regional management structure. Someone else has acquired six stores and has learned some painful lessons about integration. Another has built a meaningful fleet service business. Someone tried a new compensation structure that worked better than expected. And somebody else tried something that failed spectacularly.
Growing businesses pay tuition. We sometimes make bad hires, choose the wrong technology, overbuild certain functions, underinvest in others and occasionally pursue ideas that looked considerably better on a spreadsheet than they did in real life.
There will always be lessons you have to learn yourself. But do 10 different tire dealers really need to independently pay tuition for the same lesson? I’m not sure they do.
This becomes particularly interesting as consolidation continues to reshape the tire industry. Existing platforms are getting larger and ambitious independent tire dealers have more access to capital and acquisition opportunities than they have historically. But capital alone doesn’t build a great company. Eventually, somebody has to deploy it.
That requires leaders who know how to manage multiple locations, integrate acquisitions, recruit people, build systems, allocate resources and maintain a culture as the organization grows. Those capabilities don’t appear overnight because a private equity firm writes a check or a bank approves a loan. They have to be developed.
I wonder if a stronger culture of collaboration could help accelerate that development.
The collision industry provides an interesting example. Years of consolidation have certainly created larger companies, but they have also created an ecosystem of executives and operators who have experienced scale first-hand. People have moved between organizations. Best practices have spread. Peer groups have created forums for owners to challenge each other. Industry events have become places where meaningful operating conversations happen alongside the presentations and vendor booths.
The result isn’t that everyone operates the same way. But there is a shared body of experience that operators can draw from.
As the tire industry enters its own next chapter of consolidation, I think that kind of ecosystem becomes increasingly valuable. It could also create outcomes we don’t necessarily expect.
Two tire dealers might realize they should combine their businesses. A five-store owner might meet the person who eventually becomes their chief operating officer. Someone considering their first acquisition might learn from a peer who has already completed 10. A dealer who believes they want 50 stores might spend time with someone who already has 50 and decide they want nothing to do with it.
None of this requires giving away your competitive advantage. There are things every owner should keep close to the vest. Geography matters, competition matters and healthy rivalry is good for any industry. But there is a lot of room between protecting your competitive advantage and building your company in a vacuum. The response I get from this column makes me think the appetite is already there. Owners want to know what other owners are seeing. They want to compare notes. They want to talk about what’s working, what isn’t and what comes next.
Maybe we just need more places for those conversations to happen.
The next generation of great tire companies will need capital, technology, systems and talented people. But they may need something simpler, too: more conversations between ambitious dealers who are willing to share what they’re learning along the way. We don’t all have to make the same mistakes independently.
Am I wrong? If so, send me an invite to your next event and I’ll see you there!
About the Author
Cole StrandbergCole Strandberg
Cole Strandberg is managing director and co-head of Automotive Services at National Business Brokers, specializing in mergers and acquisitions and capital raising for multi-location tire dealerships and automotive service businesses. He can be reached at [email protected].


